Skip to content
Free Shipping on All Orders Over $35!
Free Shipping on All Orders Over $35!


6 Godmother Proposal Ideas that Won’t Break the Bank

6 Godmother Proposal Ideas that Won’t Break the Bank

You’ve done the hard work of choosing a godmother and now the fun of proposing can begin! Putting together a thoughtful proposal is a great opportunity to remind the godmother just how special she is to you and your family. Not sure where to start? Look no further - we have six godmother proposal ideas for you that are meaningful and won't break the bank. As an added bonus, they all have a turnaround time of just one business day!

1. Fairy Godmother Wine Glass

Fairy Godmother Wine Glass

Does your child's godmother love wine? This fun wine glass can add some magic to the proposal for just $15.99! There are 38 different design colors available, and the godmother's favorite color is sure to be an option. You can accompany the wine glass with a bottle of her favorite wine and a hand-written note explaining why she is the perfect pick. She’ll be sure to say yes and will treasure the memory of the proposal every time she uses the wine glass. To make this gift even more practical, you can ask us to engrave the design so the wine glass will be dishwasher safe.

Some other items you could throw in with the wine glass include her favorite chocolate, a corkscrew, or a wine-themed cookbook. You can make it even more personal with a framed photo of your child and the godmother!

2. Fairy Godmother Tall Tumbler

Fairy Godmother Tall Tumbler

Is the godmother a coffee addict or does she prefer water over wine? Then this 20-ounce tall tumbler is a must for $25.99! Your child's godmother can proudly proclaim her fairy godmother status with this tumbler in hand. They are double-walled, which reduces condensation, and can hold hot or cold liquids. Equipped with a clear lid and matching straw, these tumblers should fit most vehicle drink holders. They make an ideal gift for any godmother who is always on the go!

You can take the gift to another level by including the tumbler as part of a self-care themed gift. Remind her to slow down and take care of herself regardless of how busy her schedule may be. Thoughtful additions could include a sweet-scented candle, a gift card to her favorite local coffee shop, a hanging tea infuser for loose-leaf tea, a bath bomb, and a shower steamer.

3. Custom Quote Bodysuit

Custom Quote Bodysuit

If you’re expecting, announce your pregnancy and propose to the godmother-to-be at the same time with a custom baby bodysuit! You get to choose the font, color of the design, and what you want the bodysuit to say for $14.99. “Will you be my godmother?” with her name would be personal and get the point across!

A custom bodysuit would also work to pop the question after baby arrives. Bodysuits are available in newborn size up to 24 months, ready for the first time your child meets his or her godmother or any time after that. There are 37 different font options and 14 different design colors available for you to create a beautiful design you won't be able to find in stores!

4. Personalized Wood Photo Engraved Keychain

Personalized Wood Photo Engraved Keychain

A picture says a thousand words. If that's true, a personalized wood engraved keychain with a photo of your child and the godmother says at least a thousand more! If you're expecting, using a photo of you and the godmother could also be a fun and different way to announce your pregnancy. Just be sure to submit a professional photo with a resolution of 300 or higher if you can. Cell phone photos may lose some detail during the engraving process.

As far as unique and thoughtful godmother proposal ideas go, this gift definitely meets the criteria! We guarantee she won't have another keychain as special as this one. Since it's made out of wood, it's also incredibly lightweight. At only $11.99, why not get one for the godmother and a matching one for yourself as well?

In addition, you can let us know if you would like to personalize this keychain beyond the photo. Add a quote, names, or other text to make this gift truly one-of-a-kind!

5. Fairy Godmother Shirt

Fairy Godmother Shirt

For the godmother who has more than enough cups, perhaps a shirt would be a more fitting (pun intended) gift. These soft shirts are just $15.99 and are available in seven different colors. Like the wine glass and tall tumbler already mentioned, the design features S&S owner Taylor's own hand lettering. That means you won't find this design anywhere else!

This shirt is a fun way to celebrate the milestone of becoming a godmother that she can enjoy now and later. Pair it with the personalized baby bodysuit, but be sure to bring some tissues, just in case! We also carry this shirt in Spanish.

6. Godfather and Godmother Shirt Set

Godfather and Godmother Shirt Set

If you have both a godmother and a godfather to propose to, here's an idea for you! This shirt set is $31.99 and includes a mauve and black shirt. The design offers a subtle look, featuring both script and block fonts. You can customize the year, and the shirts make a great gift if you're proposing when you're still expecting or anytime after baby arrives. Just like the fairy godmother shirt, these shirts are super soft, so the godparents will likely wear them over and over again!

If you're uncertain of what else to include with the shirts, words go a long way! Prepare a short speech or write a letter explaining how much your child's godparents mean to you and your family. They'll be sure to feel loved and cared for during this meaningful moment of asking them to be your child's godparents.

They say it takes a village to raise a child, and godparents definitely play a special role in your child's village. We hope these godmother proposal ideas help you put together a proposal that is not only budget-friendly but meaningful and memorable as well. Though some proposal ideas out there may seem over the top, it does not take much to show others how loved and valued they are. You've got this!

Be sure to check out our shop to see all of the godmother proposal gifts we have available!

Previous article 15 Easter Basket Stuffers Under $15
Next article The 5 Best Brush Pens and Markers for Hand Lettering

Leave a comment

Comments must be approved before appearing

* Required fields